First time buying from this brand. Very happy with the mattes quality but a bit disapointed with the shimmers. (It's half the price, or more, compared to BBB or ER so of course the shimmers cannot be compared but i thought the shimmers to be very inconsistent formula thru this palette. The indigo purple for example is very hard pressed in the pan and very hard to use and other shimmers very low-key in shine but it's ok, it was produced with this finish in mind). The color story is kinda muted, grungy and versatile altho the inside organization is kinda chaotic to my taste. So i have used this palette more like a companion palette than to do full looks with only the palette. But tbh, after my initial disapointment with the shimmers, the quality is very very good for the price! If this kinda thing existed back when i first experimented with makeup i would have been over the moon. Fun color stories for affordable price and easy to use shadows! It's just than now i have bigger expectation about the shimmer and special shades etc. But I am very satisfied!